Community Corner

Supporting collaboration, exchange, & healthy change.
Welcome to Community Corner Sign in | Help
in Search

Blog or Forum or ???

Last post 02-27-2007, 4:07 PM by admin. 1 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  10-12-2006, 1:22 PM 1235

    Blog or Forum or ???

    Community Corner supports many ways of working together. In fact, it can be a bit overwhelming. Should we have a blog for our group? Maybe a discussion forum is better? Can't we just add files to the Downloads area and leave comments?

    Each of the above methods will work. How well they work depends on the skills and preferences of your user. The important question is 'what would we like to accomplish as a group?'

    Many of the previous posts in this conference highlight the benefits of the different sharing and participation features. Here are some 'rules of thumb' to selecting the approach that will work for your group.

    First, know that most people who participate are invisible. They lurk. They may read, then they click elsewhere. They are important. Their actions and comments to others have a large impact. It's similar to any public meeting. Something attracted each person to attend. A few ask questions or make statements. Some leave early, but most leave and share comments in private.

    Ideally, these lurkers should get a reasonable idea of your site's and your group's interests. Posting regularly keeps this hidden public informed and returning.

    If you want feedback, make it easy. Blogs, discussion forums, photo galleries, and file downloads can be set to accept comments.

    The first rule of thumb is 'encourage your members' by making it easy for registered members to comment.
    The other side of this rule is to 'discourage anonymous comments'. This opens up your system to spam and inappropriate content -- and creates work for the administrator.

    The second rule of thumb is 'choose the most comfortable method for your group'.
    Longer term computer users may prefer discussion forums. Others may prefer the more recent blogging and instant publishing tools. For the lurkers in your group, each approach will have a learning curve. The comfort level increases when help is available. Let them know who to contact.

    The third rule of thumb is 'forums for structured feedback; blogs for quick reactions'.
    Forums have the unique ability to present polls to the reader. This makes it easy to ask for a yes/no response to a question or to select the preferred choice from a list. Blogs, on the other hand, make it easy to add an open ended comment.

    Regardless of the approach, most groups require invitation, notification reminders, and access to support as they gain the skills to move from lurker to active online member.


    ITS Co-operative Inc.
  •  02-27-2007, 4:07 PM 3292 in reply to 1235

    Comparison chart blogs and forums

       

    Focus

    Comparing Community Corner Blogs and Forums

    Individual User

    Blogs

    Forums

    Comment

    Create topic

    Y

    Y

    Reply to existing topic

    Y

    Y

    Modify posting

    Y

    Y

    Email notification

    Y

    Y

    Attach document

    Y

    Y

    Search

    Y

    Y

    Show active and personal posts on home page

    N

    Y

    Easier to view personal interest items from forums on home page

    Add Photos and Video

    Y

    Y

    Skill requirements

    Easier to start; built in calendar index; categories optional.

    More command button options; following threads takes practice; more emphasis on replying in the right place.

    Blogs are easier for new groups.  Forums generally preferred by those with prior forum experience.

    Group Participation

    Blogs

    Forums

    Comment

    Invite comments

    Y

    Y

    5 Star Rating

    Y

    Y

    Polling

    N

    Y

    << Difference

    Share with other sites

    Y

    Y

    Participate through email

    Post new via email; cannot reply.

    Y - post new and reply, but only with add-on module

    Add-on module for forums lets people participate using email only.

    Show new items on home page

    Y

    Y

    Blog items prominently featured.

    Group Admin

    Blogs

    Forums

    Comment

    Move post to better spot.

    N

    Y

    This admin feature more necessary in forums.

    Edit existing content

    Y

    Y

    Track  and report views

    Y

    Y

    Other

    Blogs

    Forums

    Comment

    Visual layout

    Newsletter like

    Memo like

    Blogs have major visual advantages over forums.

    Print layout

    Attractive

    Limited

    Printed blogs retain their newsletter appearance.


    ITS Co-operative Inc.
View as RSS news feed in XML